Home 9 Inspiration 9 Articles 9 You Should Not Aim to Be Loved by Every Customer

You Should Not Aim to Be Loved by Every Customer

If your immediate reaction is “of course we should”, you probably have not made a strategic choice

Strengthen Customer Centricity with Facts

Through customer analytics, customer insights and CX measurement, we help businesses understand which customers create the most value and how to focus their efforts where they will have the greatest impact.

 

Most companies want more customers, more segments, more products and more revenue streams. It sounds ambitious. But it is often a sign of the opposite: a leadership team that is unwilling to choose.

The decisive strategic question is not only which customers the company wants. It is also which customers it is willing to do without. If the answer is “none”, your customer strategy is probably not a strategy. It is a wish list.

A company that wants to be relevant to everyone rarely ends up being important to anyone.

Customer centricity begins with a closed door

Customer centricity is often reduced to listening more, collecting more data and accommodating more requests. But genuine customer centricity is not about saying yes to everything. It is about creating exceptional value for a clearly defined group of customers.

Rob Markey of Bain & Company—one of the founding figures behind the NPS concept—puts the point bluntly: the first act of genuine customer centricity is exclusion. A door is only valuable because it can both open and close. Inviting certain customers inside requires the company to accept that others will remain outside.

That is not discrimination. It is strategy.

The company must decide which customer needs it wants to satisfy better than its competitors—and which needs it will not redesign the entire organisation around. Harvard Business Review makes a similar point: a company cannot develop a genuinely customer-centric strategy until it has chosen its primary customer.

Yet many leadership teams insist that “the customer is at the centre” while refusing to answer which customer they are actually talking about. That is not customer centricity. It is managerial conflict avoidance.

You are already rejecting customers

Perhaps you do not believe that your company rejects anyone. The sales organisation accepts every relevant enquiry, the products can be customised, and customer service does its best.

But rejection is happening anyway. It is simply happening without a conscious decision.

You reject your core customers when they have to wait longer because employees are spending their time developing bespoke solutions for customers who were never a good fit for the business. You reject them when the product becomes more expensive and difficult to use because it must accommodate conflicting needs. And you reject them when loyal and profitable customers are forced to finance the complexity created by less attractive ones.

The company has therefore already made a choice. Leadership has simply left that choice to short-term sales targets, chance and internal power struggles.

Is the growth strategy an escape?

When growth slows, the search for new target groups, markets and product categories often begins. It creates activity, strategy projects and presentations. But it does not answer the most uncomfortable question:

Why are your existing core customers not buying more from you?

Many companies know how much a customer buys. Far fewer know what proportion of the customer’s total spending in their category they have captured. A customer can therefore appear fully developed in the CRM system while competitors still receive most of the customer’s remaining business.

If leadership does not understand the customer’s total needs or the company’s share of wallet, it cannot know whether the core market has truly been exhausted. Yet many companies still choose to expand. Not because they have won with their core customers, but because it is more comfortable to talk about new customers than to confront the company’s lack of relevance among existing ones.

Marks & Spencer lost its edge

For decades, Marks & Spencer was one of the UK’s most respected retailers. The brand stood for quality, reliability and a clear understanding of the British middle-class customer.

Over time, however, the customer promise became less distinct. The fashion business in particular attempted to appeal to too many age groups, styles and price points. The result was not broader relevance, but confusion. At the same time, the company was burdened by an extensive and outdated store network.

Marks & Spencer did not lack initiatives. It lacked exclusion.

Its transformation in recent years has therefore focused on modernising its stores, sharpening its product range and re-establishing a clearer product and value proposition. The point is not that the company has now found a permanent formula. The point is that even a strong brand with millions of customers can lose its relevance when leadership is no longer willing to be clear about whom the company is for.

Ryanair does not want to be loved by everyone

Ryanair is not trying to be loved by everyone. That is one of the company’s greatest strengths.

Its customer promise is not luxury, flexibility or personal care. It is the opportunity to fly cheaply. If customers want checked baggage, seat selection or priority boarding, they pay extra. That is not commercial confusion. It is the model.

Ryanair has built its entire operation around one dominant customer need: low prices. Its fleet, cabin configuration, route network, choice of airports and ancillary services all support the same logic. In the 2025 financial year, the group carried approximately 200 million passengers.

Some customers hate the model. They want greater flexibility, better service and fewer rules. They should probably choose another airline. Ryanair has accepted that it does not need to change its entire operating model to satisfy them.

That is the part many executive teams are unwilling to copy. They want Ryanair’s cost discipline and scale while also being premium, flexible, personal and relevant to everyone. You can write that into a strategy. You can rarely run a company that way.

The wrong yes is not customer friendly

When a company says yes to a customer it was not designed to serve, the decision is often celebrated as commercial agility. The deal has been won, the revenue has been secured, and the budget looks better.

The problems arrive later. The product does not fit. Delivery requires exceptions. Customer service cannot meet expectations. The margin disappears, employees become frustrated, and the customer becomes dissatisfied.

The first yes gradually turns into a series of noes: no to the required functionality, no to the expected response time and no to the experience the customer was promised.

It would have been more customer-centric to say no from the beginning. It would also have been better leadership.

Exclusion is leadership’s responsibility

Ask this question at your next executive meeting:

Which customers are we not built to serve?

If the room falls silent—or someone immediately argues that the company must remain open to every opportunity—you have probably identified an area in which strategy does not yet exist.

Then ask which customers you demonstrably create more value for than your competitors. Which customers generate high revenue but destroy profitability? How much complexity have you accepted simply to avoid saying no? And what could you do significantly better for your most important customers if you stopped spending resources on everyone else?

Strategy is not about setting the greatest possible number of ambitions. It is about making choices under constraints.

When executive leadership refuses to exclude customers, the risk does not disappear. It is simply passed on to employees, core customers and shareholders.

The question is therefore not whether your company is rejecting customers. It already is.

The question is whether executive leadership is making that choice—or whether you are allowing your best customers to pay the price because nobody is willing to do it.